Hunton Insurance Recovery Blog

Last week, the Ninth Circuit affirmed fraud convictions for Theranos’ former CEO, Elizabeth Holmes, and former COO, Ramesh Balwani, upholding an order finding both defendants personally liable for $452 million in restitution to various Theranos investors. While it remains to be seen whether the embattled executives will pursue further appeals to the US Supreme Court, the years of litigation and appeals following Theranos’s untimely demise in 2018 highlight the importance of directors and officers having robust “final adjudication” language in conduct exclusions found in all D&O liability policies.

The Supreme Court of California has ruled that a general liability insurer must defend an employer against allegations of employee misconduct, reinforcing the breadth of (1) what constitutes an “occurrence” under an employer’s commercial general liability (CGL) policy and (2) the duty to defend regarding claims for negligent hiring, retention and supervision. The opinion in Liberty Surplus Ins. Corp. v. Ledesma & Meyer Constr. Co., Inc. can be found here.